Friday, November 20, 2026 Today's paperNewslettersSearch
Verdmere

Independent news on climate and the living world

Opinion · Column

The planters on Ashby Vale are not the problem. The way we argue about them is

A low-traffic scheme cut rat-running by half and barely touched the main road. The fight over it has still divided a neighbourhood. There is a better way to have these arguments.

· Editor-in-chief · Published Thursday, November 19, 2026, 06:30 ET · 3 min read

Opinion pieces are the writer's view, not Verdmere's.

Wooden planters closing a residential street to through traffic. Illustration: Verdmere

I have covered planning rows for most of my working life, and I have rarely seen one as bitter as the argument over eleven wooden planters in Ashby Vale.

For those who have not followed it: eighteen months ago, the borough council closed a handful of residential streets to through traffic, using planters and two camera-enforced gates. Residents can still drive to their homes; they just cannot use the neighbourhood as a short cut between the ring road and the high street. The council called it a trial. Its opponents called it a blockade. Last month the council voted, by a single seat, to make it permanent.

You've read 3 free articles this month

Create a free account to keep reading

Without an account you can read 3 articles a month. A free account gives you 10, and a subscription unlimited access.

Create a free account Subscribe Sign in

low-traffic neighbourhoodsstreetslocal democracy
Save for later Report an error

About the author

Ruth Callander, Editor-in-chief. Ruth founded Verdmere's newsroom after fifteen years covering environmental courts and local government. She writes a column on Sundays.

Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Sign in or create a free account to comment.