Opinion · Column
When a company’s carbon figure is wrong, it is not a rounding error. It is a broken promise
Emissions numbers have become the currency of climate action. We should treat them with the seriousness we reserve for money.
Opinion pieces are the writer's view, not Verdmere's.
Early in my career I spent a winter in a county court watching a planning dispute over a quarry extension. The arguments that mattered were not about landscape or lorries. They were about a single figure, the tonnage of stone extracted the previous year, which turned out to have been reported to the council as roughly half the true amount. The case collapsed when the number did.
I thought about that quarry this week, as a pension fund took a cement maker to court over its carbon accounts. I do not know who will win, and nor does anyone else yet. But the case raises a question that matters far beyond one company: what do we expect of a number?
The currency of climate action
Over the past decade, emissions figures have quietly become the currency of climate policy. Companies borrow against them through so-called sustainability-linked loans. Investors build funds around them. Governments design carbon levies and border taxes that depend on them. Councils score procurement contracts on them. Almost every promise made in the name of net zero is denominated in tonnes of carbon dioxide.
And yet we still treat those tonnes with a looseness we would never tolerate for pounds. A company that misstated its revenue by a third would face regulators, auditors and, quite possibly, a criminal investigation. A company that misstates its emissions by a third faces, at most, a sternly worded report from a campaign group.
That gap is not sustainable. If the figures that underpin climate finance cannot be trusted, then the money flowing through it is being allocated in the dark.
If the figures that underpin climate finance cannot be trusted, then the money flowing through it is being allocated in the dark.
What good looks like
None of this means every company is cheating. Carbon accounting is genuinely hard. Supply chains are long, fuel records are messy and the rules have changed several times. Honest mistakes will happen, and companies that find and correct them should be applauded rather than punished.
But three things would help. Emissions figures in annual reports should be audited to the same standard as the financial statements beside them, not merely “reviewed”. The assumptions behind them, particularly those that make fuels or offsets look cleaner than they are, should be published in full. And when a figure turns out to be wrong, the correction should be as prominent as the original claim.
That last point applies to newspapers too. In this newsroom we print corrections when we get things wrong, and we put them at the top of the article rather than burying them. It is uncomfortable, and it is the only way readers can trust the rest of what we publish.
The quarry case taught me that a single number can carry the weight of an entire argument. Climate policy now rests on millions of them. We owe it to ourselves to check they are true.
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Sign in or create a free account to comment.