Food & Farming · Investigation Members
Grazing without fertiliser: what the accounts of 22 farms reveal about regenerative beef
Regenerative grazing is sold as good for soil and good for business. We obtained five years of farm accounts to test the second claim. The answer is more interesting than the slogans on either side.
On a wet morning in October, Helen Garside unrolled a length of white electric tape across a field above the village of Saltby Moor and opened a gap at one end. Sixty-two cattle, mostly Hereford crosses, walked through it into grass that reached their knees. Tomorrow she will move them again. No bagged fertiliser has been spread on this farm for six years. “People think this is a lifestyle choice,” she said, wiping rain off her glasses. “It isn’t. I did it because the numbers on the old system had stopped working.”
Regenerative grazing, in which livestock are moved frequently around small paddocks and the grass is left to recover for weeks between grazings, has become one of the most talked-about ideas in farming. Supporters say it rebuilds soil, stores carbon and cuts costs. Sceptics say the claims run ahead of the evidence, and that such farms simply produce less food. Most of that debate has focused on soil and carbon; far less has been published on the money. So over the past four months, Verdmere worked with the Westmoor Farm Business Survey, a long-running accounting project run by the University of Eastmoor, to analyse anonymised financial records for 2020 to 2024 from 22 upland beef and sheep farms. Eleven have used rotational, regenerative grazing for at least five years. The other 11 are conventional farms of similar size, altitude and soil type, matched by the university’s economists.
Members only
This long read is for Verdmere members
Subscribe to read it in full, along with every story we publish. Digital is $8 a month; new subscribers pay $1 for the first month.
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Comments are closed. We close comments 7 days after an article is published.